Should women be charged with a crime for making false rape allegations?

1. 2018-09-20 at 10:08 PM UTC

   #1
   

   mmQ Lisa Turtle
   I know it's not a new topic, but why doesn't it happen? It seems like anywhere I see, the general consensus is yes, they should. Why do you think it's not like that? Why is it legal to lie about someone else committing a crime?
   
   I like to think I have a decent understanding of how our justice system works but I don't see the benefit in allowing false claims to go unpunished.
   
   Thoughts?
2. 2018-09-20 at 10:18 PM UTC

   #2
   

   POLECAT POLECAT is a motherfucking ferret [my presentably immunised ammonification]
   yes,, or they could opp for the rape they claimed happened
3. 2018-09-20 at 10:20 PM UTC

   #3
   

   RisiR † 29 Autism
   Here in Germany it's a crime to falsly accuse someone of a crime.
4. 2018-09-20 at 10:20 PM UTC

   #4
   

   mmQ Lisa Turtle

   Originally posted by POLECAT yes,, or they could opp for the rape they claimed happened

   
   Yes, tenfold.
5. 2018-09-20 at 10:21 PM UTC

   #5
   

   mmQ Lisa Turtle

   Originally posted by RisiR † Here in Germany it's a crime to falsly accuse someone of a crime.

   
   Do you have any examples? Like what level of crime is it? If you falsely accuse murder, would you then be charged with murder, or I should say, the equivelant of murder technically, whatever, you know what I mean.
6. 2018-09-20 at 10:24 PM UTC

   #6
   DontTellEm Black Hole
   If I were to be raped, I wouldn't let anyone else decide my Justice.
   
   It's a thin line in terms of the "system"...it is hard to prove, & it can be easily abused.
7. 2018-09-20 at 10:24 PM UTC

   #7
   

   infinityshock Black Hole

   Originally posted by mmQ I know it's not a new topic, but why doesn't it happen? It seems like anywhere I see, the general consensus is yes, they should. Why do you think it's not like that? Why is it legal to lie about someone else committing a crime?
   
   I like to think I have a decent understanding of how our justice system works but I don't see the benefit in allowing false claims to go unpunished.
   
   Thoughts?

   
   i know of a chick who made a false rape claim.
   
   she claimed some dude invited her to his house and raped her.
   
   the problem: during the time she claims to have been raped...on official record...the house was full of about a dozen people who independently verified the chick hadnt even been to the house during the days before and after she claimed rape.
   
   her punishment: 6 months probation and a few hundred dollars fine.
8. 2018-09-20 at 10:25 PM UTC

   #8
   

   mmQ Lisa Turtle

   Originally posted by DontTellEm If I were to be raped, I wouldn't let anyone else decide my Justice.
   
   It's a thin line in terms of the "system"…it is hard to prove, & it can be easily abused.

   
   Right. This isn't about anyone being raped. It's about fake being raped.
9. 2018-09-20 at 10:28 PM UTC

   #9
   

   RisiR † 29 Autism

   Originally posted by mmQ Do you have any examples? Like what level of crime is it? If you falsely accuse murder, would you then be charged with murder, or I should say, the equivelant of murder technically, whatever, you know what I mean.

   
   According to StGB §164 the penalty is 6 month to 5 years prison or a monetary fine. In 2016 (last update) over 16.000 cases of "falsche Verdächtigung" were reported.
10. 2018-09-20 at 10:28 PM UTC

    #10
    DontTellEm Black Hole
    Ya. Hence "if"
    
    Also, I will spit on a mother fuckers grave. That's just me tho. ☺️
11. 2018-09-20 at 10:32 PM UTC

    #11
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by RisiR † According to StGB §164 the penalty is 6 month to 5 years prison or a monetary fine. In 2016 (last update) over 16.000 cases of "falsche Verdächtigung" were reported.

    
    Well that's nice that they do something about it at the very least. I wonder what they do to the false claimed in cases where a person has been incarcerated for years, and then gets exhonerated. It doesn't feel like it should be a one size fits all level punishment.
12. 2018-09-20 at 10:32 PM UTC

    #12
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by DontTellEm Ya. Hence "if"
    
    Also, I will spit on a mother fuckers grave. That's just me tho. ☺️

    
    What the hell are you talking about? Jesus Christ.
13. 2018-09-20 at 10:33 PM UTC

    #13
    DontTellEm Black Hole
    Um. Can u read?
14. 2018-09-20 at 10:34 PM UTC

    #14
    Nil African Astronaut [the overexcited four-footed chanar]

    Originally posted by mmQ What the hell are you talking about? Jesus Christ.

    
    Every single post they make is a non-sequitur.
    The following users say it would be alright if the author of this post didn't die in a fire!

    • mmQ
15. 2018-09-20 at 10:35 PM UTC

    #15
    

    HTS highlight reel
    Whatever they were falsely accusing people should be done to them. So: punitive rape, in this case.
16. 2018-09-20 at 10:38 PM UTC

    #16
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by Nil Every single post they make is a non-sequitur.

    
    No shit huh?
    
    
    
    

    Originally posted by HTS Whatever they were falsely accusing people should be done to them. So: punitive rape, in this case.

    
    I feel like this would solve so much.
17. 2018-09-20 at 10:40 PM UTC

    #17
    DontTellEm Black Hole
    1 + 1
    Counts fingers slowly....
    
    🤔😊
    Lol. Simple mother fucker.
18. 2018-09-20 at 10:50 PM UTC

    #18
    DontTellEm Black Hole
    Wren?
    
    Lol. When IF I spit on ur grave I wanna be sure u know what exactly it means.
19. 2018-09-20 at 10:56 PM UTC

    #19
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle
    Go on then. Clarify what you mean in relation to my original post and what I asked. A straightforward question with a straightforward answer. Go ahead.
20. 2018-09-20 at 11:01 PM UTC

    #20
    DontTellEm Black Hole
    Sure.
    I responded, I wouldn't let a judicial system decide what Justice were for me, if I were to be Raped.
    
    Then, I said I would spit on a stupid mother fuckers grave.
    (Movie reference)