User Controls

How come there has never been an experimental electronic band as good as Skinny Puppy?

  1. #1
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    There are thousands of bands within the "Industrial" spectrum of music and none of them (aside for NIN, Coil and Contagious Orgasm) come close to the sublime production quality and artistry of Skinny Puppy.







    Seriously.
    There are so many imitators and bands of "similar" style, but none of them have been able to achieve the perfection of 1980s Skinny Puppy.
    This isn't an SP worship thread, rather it's me pointing out the fact that SP was able to pull off their sound with such masterful perfection meanwhile other electro-industrial and post-industrial bands sound so sterile in comparison.
    Even bands I genuinely enjoy have this quality to them that is either amateurish or sloppy.
    There isn't a single electro-industrial band that has ever been able to create an album (let alone several of them) that feel like they deserve a permanent spot on history's album shelf.
    I hope to one day be able to produce such quality works as 1980s Skinny Puppy.
  2. #2
    Ask ur mom
  3. #3
    aldra JIDF Controlled Opposition
    Haujobb, though it's a different style. they manage to keep putting out unique stuff significantly longer than SP too, though more slowly
  4. #4
    aldra JIDF Controlled Opposition


  5. #5
    Jean Michelle Jarre for all your experimental electronic music needs.
  6. #6
    L41n Houston
    MBM is better
  7. #7
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    Originally posted by L41n MBM is better

    meat beat manifesto is for the gay man
  8. #8
    L41n Houston
    Originally posted by Japan-Is-Eternal meat beat manifesto is for the gay man

    skinny puppy is for clove smoking emos
    The following users say it would be alright if the author of this post didn't die in a fire!
  9. #9
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    Originally posted by L41n skinny puppy is for clove smoking emos

    Skinny Puppy is too abrasive and experimental for emos
  10. #10
    L41n Houston
    Originally posted by Japan-Is-Eternal Skinny Puppy is too abrasive and experimental for emos

    What kind of wuss thinks Skinny Puppy "abrasive" and "experimental"?
  11. #11
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    Originally posted by L41n What kind of wuss thinks Skinny Puppy "abrasive" and "experimental"?

    Have you even listened to them beyond the singles/hits?





  12. #12
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    also you're an idiot if you don't think Skinny Puppy is experimental

    they literally took noise and Industrial and fused it with electro and EBM






    Nobody was doing anything remotely as innovative as Skinny Puppy back then or since

    also you listen to meat beat manifesto, you are a clueless plebe.
  13. #13
    L41n Houston
    Originally posted by Japan-Is-Eternal blah blah blah

    Wikipedia lists Skinny Puppys genres as: "Industrial[1] EBM[2] electro-industrial[3] industrial rock[4] techno[5]"

    Compare this with MBM: "Post-industrial electronic industrial experimental[1]" or Foetus: "Post-punk experimental avant-garde industrial"

    So, in addition to being a sniveling idiot, you're a basic bitch QED
  14. #14
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    >he gets his musical opinions from a wikipedia article
  15. #15
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    also foetus is basic bitch /mu/core for retards that don't know what Industrial is
  16. #16
    L41n Houston
    Originally posted by Japan-Is-Eternal >he gets his musical opinions from a wikipedia article

    I'm a girl dumbass, and yea wikipedia represents a consensus as opposed to your singular opinion that one of the most mainstream and popular industrial acts is "experimental".
  17. #17
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    Just because they're more visible doesn't take away from the fact that they're experimental

    You obviously just discovered Industrial music rather recently, and probably through /mu/ and or RYM at that so your opinion is null and void.

    >wikipedia represents a consensus

    Take your groupthink and shove it up your nasty vagina

    you probably think Einsturzende Neubauten and Cabaret Voltaire are Industrial, don'tcha.

    kill yourself
  18. #18
    aldra JIDF Controlled Opposition
    wut

    why would you say EN wasn't
  19. #19
    L41n Houston
    Originally posted by Japan-Is-Eternal and probably through /mu/

    I don't go on 4chan because I'm not an edgelord dumbass like you.

    Why don't you go watch Fantano videos on yt and stop clogging up the forum with your stupid opinions?
    The following users say it would be alright if the author of this post didn't die in a fire!
  20. #20
    Japan-Is-Eternal Naturally Camouflaged
    Originally posted by aldra wut

    why would you say EN wasn't

    Because they aren't.
    This is a very popular misconception.
    People think that because they used construction equipment to make their music and incorporated elements of noise that that makes them Industrial.
    Industrial music is essentially psychedelic rock infused with noise music:
Jump to Top