NIS Mafia (Game Thread)

1. 2017-04-25 at 6:11 AM UTC

   #41
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole

   Originally posted by RisiR Number13….
   
   Register.

   
   Number 13 is dead and therefore cannot be the rat.
2. 2017-04-25 at 6:14 AM UTC

   #42
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   The current game is ongoing, you cannot register until it is over. You must now vote on who the rat is for this game.
   
   We have 1 vote for Darth Beaver, 1 vote for RisiR and 1 vote for someone who definitely can't be the rat.
   
   We need a majority vote to decide who the rat is.
3. 2017-04-25 at 6:51 AM UTC

   #43
   

   mmQ Lisa Turtle
   Omfg it's so obvious hurry up round 2 let's go9o.
4. 2017-04-25 at 6:54 AM UTC

   #44
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   I'm changing my vote to RisiR.
5. 2017-04-25 at 11:11 AM UTC

   #45
   

   Sophie Pedophile Tech Support
   I am voting for TDR, he was all too keen on pointing fingers as soon as we learned Number13 was dead.
   
   *This is me registering for round 2.*
6. 2017-04-25 at 1:55 PM UTC

   #46
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   Ok ok.. keep making rules up.
   
   TDR
7. 2017-04-25 at 2:14 PM UTC

   #47
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   OK tie, now what?
8. 2017-04-25 at 6:48 PM UTC

   #48
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   Discussion will continue unless one of you convinces another to break the tie.
9. 2017-04-25 at 7:09 PM UTC

   #49
   The Self Taught Man Black Hole
   I'm just guessing at RisiR but if I change my vote now it's game over. So I've got to stand by my first guess.
10. 2017-04-25 at 7:35 PM UTC

    #50
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle
    I don't see how any of this "discussion" provides any clues. The killer isn't obligated to say anything at all, right? Obviously everyone is going to deny it (though the better strategy would be to admit you're the killer).
    
    Am I missing something? How can someone deem another the killer based off of a few shitposts where everyone blames someone else but no real CLUES are offered ?
11. 2017-04-25 at 7:40 PM UTC

    #51
    The Self Taught Man Black Hole

    Originally posted by mmQ I don't see how any of this "discussion" provides any clues. The killer isn't obligated to say anything at all, right? Obviously everyone is going to deny it (though the better strategy would be to admit you're the killer).
    
    Am I missing something? How can someone deem another the killer based off of a few shitposts where everyone blames someone else but no real CLUES are offered ?

    There can't be clues because nothing really happened.
12. 2017-04-25 at 7:40 PM UTC

    #52
    

    Sophie Pedophile Tech Support
    Sorry for the meta post but i think there should be a time limit on our second round of deliberation since obviously if we never change our votes the game will never progress.
13. 2017-04-25 at 7:42 PM UTC

    #53
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by Darth Beaver There can't be clues because nothing really happened.

    
    Well right so what's the fucking point with the whole killer and victim thing? Why not just say I'm gonna pm someone and other people have to guess who I pmd based off nothing.
14. 2017-04-25 at 7:43 PM UTC

    #54
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle
    I'm gonna think up a better version of this . THANK YOU.
15. 2017-04-25 at 7:44 PM UTC

    #55
    The Self Taught Man Black Hole

    Originally posted by Sophie Sorry for the meta post but i think there should be a time limit on our second round of deliberation since obviously if we never change our votes the game will never progress.

    
    Agreed on the vote but what would a time limit accomplish? I mean let's say the time limit was over the moment I clicked submit for this post and the vote was as it is now. How would no further discussion solve the deadlock?
16. 2017-04-25 at 7:46 PM UTC

    #56
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by Darth Beaver How would no further discussion solve the deadlock?

    
    It would end the round with no winner.
17. 2017-04-25 at 7:46 PM UTC

    #57
    The Self Taught Man Black Hole

    Originally posted by mmQ It would end the round with no winner.

    
    What is the point of a game that can't be won?
18. 2017-04-25 at 7:54 PM UTC

    #58
    

    mmQ Lisa Turtle

    Originally posted by Darth Beaver What is the point of a game that can't be won?

    
    It can be won. Just not always. Soccer, football, hockey, all have time limits and can end in a draw. But like I said I'm going to make a better version of this anyway, one where there will always be a winner, and there will be CLUES.
19. 2017-04-25 at 8:36 PM UTC

    #59
    The Self Taught Man Black Hole

    Originally posted by mmQ It can be won. Just not always. Soccer, football, hockey, all have time limits and can end in a draw. But like I said I'm going to make a better version of this anyway, one where there will always be a winner, and there will be CLUES.

    
    Dooweet. I'll register.
20. 2017-04-25 at 8:52 PM UTC

    #60
    The Self Taught Man Black Hole
    OK, the way it stands myself and Dargo have guessed RisiR. While Sophie and RisiR have guessed me. So without regard to who the rat may actually be in locally can't change my guess unless or until RisiR or Sophie changes their vote. If I am the rat changing my vote ends the game and I lose. If I am not the rat and I change my vote I die and I lose. That us really all the more discussion I can offer this go round.